Buying Wine
Who Actually Makes Store-Brand Wine?
The label is legally required to tell you whether the name on the front fermented the wine or just bought it. Here is the wording to look for, and what it does not prove.
Usually a real winery, and the label is legally required to hint at which one. The phrase sitting in front of the bottler’s name is the tell. “Produced and bottled by” means that company fermented the wine. “Cellared and bottled by” means somebody else did, and the name on the front is closer to a customer than a maker.
The verb in front of the address is doing all the work
Every US wine label has to carry a name and address introduced by wording like “bottled by.” That wording is not marketing copy. Each phrase is defined in federal regulation, and they set very different bars.
| Wording on the label | What it requires | Who fermented it |
|---|---|---|
| Estate bottled | The winery controls 100 percent of the grapes, and crushing through bottling all happen at one place inside the named growing area | The winery |
| Produced and bottled by | At least 75 percent of the wine was fermented at that address | Mostly the winery |
| Made and bottled by | The same 75 percent threshold as produced | Mostly the winery |
| Cellared and bottled by, or vinted by | The wine was aged, blended or finished there after arriving | Someone else |
| Bottled by | The wine was packaged there | Someone else |
A store brand reading “produced and bottled by” is pointing at a working winery that put its own address on the bottle. One reading “cellared and bottled by” is quietly saying the wine was bought in and blended. If the label decoding side of this is new to you, our guide to reading a wine label covers the rest of the small print.
Kirkland is the clearest worked example
Costco’s Kirkland Signature range is the most picked-over private label in wine, and it spans the whole spectrum. The boxed wine is produced by E. and J. Gallo, a fact traceable through federal filings rather than any press release. Higher up the range the pairings get specific: Kirkland Premier Cru Chablis has been made by Pierre Brissy, the winemaker behind Jean-Marc Brocard, and the Cotes du Rhone Villages by Patrick Lesec.
Costco now prints the producer or winemaker on many of these labels outright. That is the habit worth checking on any retailer brand, whether you are in a warehouse club or picking something up at the grocery store. Silence on the back label does not prove anything bad, but it does put you back to reading the wording.
The bonded winery number is the tiebreaker
When the wording is vague, there is still a serial number. Every bonded US wine facility has a registry number that looks like BW-CA-1234, sometimes written BWN or BWC, and regulations allow it on the label only in direct conjunction with the name and address of whoever operates that facility. It identifies a physical bonded premises, not a brand, so it survives whatever the front label is calling itself this year.
Two bottles carrying the same BW number came out of the same building. That is often how people work out that a supermarket label and a familiar winery share an address.
What none of this proves
Knowing the maker tells you about provenance. It does not tell you the wine is good.
- Bulk-bought blends can be genuinely well made, because the buyer is choosing from a large pool of finished wine.
- An estate-bottled wine from a mediocre site is still a mediocre wine, however strict the term is.
- Retailer labels can change source between batches while the label stays identical, so last year’s bottle is not a promise about this year’s.
So the wording settles provenance, and stops there. Provenance is one input into whether a bottle is actually good value, sitting alongside price and what is in the glass.
AboutWine reads the label with you and explains its reasoning instead of handing you a number. Download it on the App Store.
Frequently asked questions
Does store-brand wine come from real wineries?
Often yes. Established wineries sell wine under retailer labels to move volume without discounting their own brand. The label wording tells you whether the named company fermented the wine or only bottled it.
What is the difference between produced by and bottled by?
Produced and bottled by means at least 75 percent of the wine was fermented at that address. Bottled by means the company only packaged it, and someone else made it.
Is store-brand wine lower quality than branded wine?
Not necessarily. A retailer label skips the marketing budget, so the same money buys more wine. What you give up is consistency, because the source can change between batches without the label changing.
Keep reading
What Wine Goes With Ham? The Glaze Decides
What wine goes with ham depends on the glaze, not the meat. Why sugar breaks a dry bottle, what to pour for each kind of ham, and the one wine for a full table.
What Wine Should You Use for Mulled Wine?
Skip the listicle. Here is what heat, sugar and spice actually do to a bottle, which grapes survive it, and how much to spend on wine for mulled wine.
What Wine Goes With Cacio e Pepe?
Cacio e pepe is salt, fat and black pepper, which rules out most big tannic reds. Here is what to buy instead, from a Roman Frascati to a crisp Verdicchio.
