Buying Wine
Two Vintages of the Same Wine. Does the Year Matter?
The shelf has two years of the same bottle. Here is when the vintage actually changes the wine, when it changes nothing, and how to decide in ten seconds.
Usually not, and the exception is narrow. If a wine costs under about twenty dollars and comes from a warm, reliable region, take the newer bottle and stop thinking about it. The year starts to matter when the climate is variable, the producer is small, and the wine is built to age, which describes a minority of what sits on a shop shelf.
What the year actually records
The vintage is not a quality grade. It records when the grapes were picked, and nothing more.
What it implies is weather. A cool, wet summer gives thinner, sharper wine; a hot one gives riper, softer, higher-alcohol wine. In places where the weather barely moves from year to year, that implication carries almost no information. In places where it swings, it carries a lot. Everything else people read into a vintage year is inference stacked on top of that one fact.
When the year changes the wine
Two things decide it: climate and price.
| Wine on the shelf | Does the year matter | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Under $20, warm region such as Mendoza or La Mancha | Barely | Take the newest one |
| Non-vintage Champagne, marked NV | Not by design | The blend is the product |
| $20 to $50 from Burgundy, the Mosel, the Loire, Oregon | Somewhat | Worth a second look |
| $50 and up, small producer, built to age | Yes | The year is part of the wine |
The first row covers most of what people actually buy. Inexpensive wine made at scale is blended and adjusted to taste the same every year, which is a feature for the people making it and a reason to ignore the vintage for the people drinking it.
Three questions at the shelf
You can settle this faster than you can read a back label.
- What does it cost? Under roughly twenty dollars, year-to-year differences are deliberately engineered out. Price and quality are their own tangle, covered in how much to spend on a bottle.
- Where is it from? Warm and dry means consistency. Cool or marginal, where ripening is not guaranteed, means real variation between years.
- When are you drinking it? If the answer is Friday, the year matters far less than how the bottle was stored. A sunlit shop window does more damage than a mediocre season.
If the label itself is the obstacle, how to read a wine label covers the rest of what is printed there.
Why vintage charts mislead
A vintage chart compresses an entire region and an entire season into one number. That is a useful summary of the weather and a poor guide to a specific bottle.
Within any region in any year, sites drain differently, growers pick on different dates, and some producers declassify their weaker lots while others bottle everything. A careful producer in a hard year routinely makes better wine than an indifferent one in a celebrated year. The chart cannot see any of that, because a single score has no room to explain itself, which is the same limitation behind why wine ratings can be unreliable.
The useful question is never what the year scored. It is whether this wine, from this place, at this price, is the kind that changes from year to year at all. For most bottles, the honest answer is no.
Want a wine app that explains its reasoning instead of handing you a number? Download AboutWine free on the App Store.
Frequently asked questions
Is a newer vintage better than an older one on the shelf?
For everyday wine, newer is usually the safer pick, because most of it is made to drink young and loses freshness sitting in a warm shop. For age-worthy wine from a good producer, the older bottle may be the better one, provided it was stored properly. Shop storage is the variable nobody prints on the label.
What does NV mean on a bottle?
It means non-vintage, and it is a deliberate choice rather than a missing detail. Champagne houses blend across several years to keep a consistent house style, so the absence of a year is the point. Asking which vintage an NV Champagne is misunderstands what it is for.
Should I trust a vintage chart?
Treat it as weather data, not a verdict. A chart scores an entire region with one number, but a careful producer in a difficult year often makes better wine than an average one in a celebrated year. The chart tells you what the season was like, not what any particular bottle tastes like.
Keep reading
What Wine Goes With Ham? The Glaze Decides
What wine goes with ham depends on the glaze, not the meat. Why sugar breaks a dry bottle, what to pour for each kind of ham, and the one wine for a full table.
What Wine Should You Use for Mulled Wine?
Skip the listicle. Here is what heat, sugar and spice actually do to a bottle, which grapes survive it, and how much to spend on wine for mulled wine.
What Wine Goes With Cacio e Pepe?
Cacio e pepe is salt, fat and black pepper, which rules out most big tannic reds. Here is what to buy instead, from a Roman Frascati to a crisp Verdicchio.
